 |
Judges - please email critiques to Julie at collielife1@gmail.com.
Our Dogs - showreports@ourdogs.co.uk
If you cannot find a critique for a show - you can complete a form on KC website HERE
2025
Show and Link to Critique |
Judge |
password for critiques below *******4A |
|
Stacy Steven |
|
Jacky Cutler |
|
Elena J. Balazsovits, FCI judge, Hungary. |
|
Stefani Flower |
|
Sue Beare |
|
Marianne Benton |
|
Stacy Steven |
|
Janina Britton |
|
Vanessa Cronk |
|
Mike Vincent |
|
Nick Smith |
|
Sheila Telford |
|
Phil Amos |
|
Jake Walsh |
|
Christine Collins |
|
John Blake |
|
Lorraine Quince |
|
Doug Bedford |
|
Gary Clarke |
|
Sue Beare |
|
Sue Hawkins |
|
Sue Beare |
|
Stacy Steven |
|
Cathy Howard |
|
Christine Collins |
|
Terry Carlton |
|
Wendy Musty |
|
Margaret Shipp |
|
Sophie Wray-Ramsden |
|
Di Collino |
|
Gina Stilwell |
|
Howard Ogden |
|
Bill Rogerson |
|
Marina McLaughlin |
|
Sue Hawkins |
|
Anita Fox |
|
Stephen Clark |
|
Mike Vincent |
|
Shelley Skinner |
|
Lyn Maxwell |
|
Lucy Mottram |
|
Iain Forbes |
|
Jackie Dix |
|
Karen McDevitt |
|
new password for critiques below *s******5 |
|
Bev White |
|
Wendy Smith |
|
Di Collino |
|
Josie Large |
|
Karen Angier |
|
Kay Hateley |
|
Bill Browne-Cole |
|
Cath Moffat |
|
Jane Margetts |
|
Cathy Howard |
|
Michael Wirth |
|
Tina May |
|
Tracey Wilkinson |
|
Felicity Snook |
|
Simon Luxmoore |
|
Darren Clarke |
|
EACA Ch Show Rough Collie Dogs and Stakes |
Tomas Rohlin |
Colin Bartram |
|
EACA Ch Show Rough Collie Bitches and Smooth Collies |
Jan Milligan |
Sue Randall |
|
K R Newhouse |
|
Jo Denton |
|
Simon Burton |
|
Lisa Tyler-Jackson |
|
Stefani Flower |
|
Simon Luxmoore |
|
Joshua Blackburn |
|
Sheila Telford |
|
Louise Walker |
|
Fay Hutchings |
|
Charlotte Vescan |
|
Louise Walker |
|
Marion Withers |
|
Rachel Tilley |
|
Jane Stevens |
|
Stephen Webb |
|
Cathy Proctor |
|
Denise Rowan |
|
Marianne Benton |
|
Yorkshire Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Bitches |
Fran Kaye |
Yorkshire Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Dogs |
Hannah Walder |
Jo Williams |
|
Josep Maria Cabano |
|
Brian Hawkins |
|
Michelle Davis |
|
Craig Sloan |
|
Karen Johnston |
|
Keith Baldwin |
|
Rachel Tilley |
|
Hazel Allsopp |
|
Keith Baldwin |
|
Simon Luxmoore |
|
Sophie Wray-Ramsden |
|
Anne Hassock |
|
Loraine Ratter |
|
Sally Duffin |
|
Toni Jackson |
|
Espen Engh |
|
Abby Lusty |
|
Marina McLaughlin |
|
Ann Page |
|
Marion Withers |
|
Marianne Grindley |
|
Marion Withers |
|
Abby Lusty |
|
Gareth Brown |
|
Sam Wrisdale |
|
Hannah Walder |
|
Simon Walder |
|
Tim Ball |
|
Irene Buchanan Green |
|
Val Geddes |
|
Hazel Allsopp |
|
Alan Staniland |
|
Tan Nagrecha |
|
Sue Butterfield |
|
Frank Kane |
|
Melanie Jane Lewis |
|
John Congdon |
|
Marina McLaughlin |
|
Lynda Nicholas |
|
Joanne Goodbrand |
|
Cara Davani |
|
Tom Johnston |
|
Eleanor Kitchen |
|
Eleanor Kitchen |
|
Ed Forsey |
|
Michelle Davis |
|
Show and Link to Critique |
Judge |
Jo White |
|
Sue Beare |
|
Alan Jones |
|
Karen Colman-Smith |
|
Carole Smedley |
|
British Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Dogs |
Rod Slater |
British Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Bitches |
Marie Magill |
British Collie Club Ch Show Smooth Collies |
Birgit Hayward |
Herts and Essex Border Rough and Smooth Collies |
Joanne Denton |
Yorkshire Collie Club Open Show Rough Collies |
Georgina Howard |
Angela Pedder |
|
Marina McLaughlin |
|
Annette Walters |
|
Bill Rogerson |
|
North of Scotland Shetland Sheepdog Club Rough and Smooth Collies |
Lorraine Quince |
Jake Walsh |
|
Smooth Collie Club of GB Smooth Collies - Show 2 |
Cath Moffat |
Smooth Collie Club of GB Best in Show - Show 2 |
Cathy Howard |
EACA Open Show - Show 1 Rough Collies |
Di Collino |
EACA Open Show - Show 1 Smooth Collies |
Di Collino |
EACA Open Show - Show 2 Rough and Smooth Collies |
Marion Withers |
Lancs and Cheshire Ch Show Smooth Collies |
Bev White |
Lancs and Cheshire Ch Show Rough Collies dogs and bitches |
Jim and Morag McCarte |
West of England Collie Society Rough Collies |
Sue Beare |
Birmingham National Rough Collies |
J Gregory |
Birmingham National Smooth Collies |
Ann French |
Scottish Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Bitches |
Caz Waterhouse |
Scottish Collie Club Ch Show Best in Show |
Frances Kaye |
Manchester Rough Collies |
Kay Hateley |
Yorkshire Collie Club Open Show Rough Collies |
Jo Denton |
Yorkshire Collie Club Open Show Best in Show |
Rod Slater |
Yorkshire Collie Club Open Show Smooth Collies |
Sue Hawkins |
Yorkshire Collie Club Open Show Rough Collies SAC |
Stephen Webb |
Ayrshire Collie Club Open Show Rough Collies |
Ann French |
Scottish Kennel Club - October show Rough Collies |
Bev White |
Riddings and District Rough and Smooth Collies |
Angela Harvey |
London Collie Club Ch Show Smooth Collies |
Geoff Duffield |
London Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Bitches |
Sue Randall |
London Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Dogs |
Doreen Clarke |
London Collie Club Ch Show Best in Show |
Darren Clarke |
Working and Pastoral Breeds of Wales Rough Collies |
Simon Burton |
Cathy Howard |
|
Bath Rough Collies |
Russell Jones |
Cheltenham Rough Collies |
Josie Large |
Sophie Wray-Ramsden |
|
Ian Entwistle |
|
Mandy Davies |
|
Joan Fryer-Clark |
|
Bridgette Bodle |
|
Jo Williams (nee White) |
|
Carole Smedley |
|
Rachel Tilley |
|
Jacky Pritchard |
|
Mrs S Juutilainen |
|
Smooth Collie Club of GB Open Show Rough Collies |
Sheila Beeney |
Scottish Kennel Club Rough Collies |
Michelle Mitchell |
National Working and Pastoral Breeds Rough Collies |
Aly King |
Windsor Rough Collies |
Terry Colwell |
Scottish Collie Club Championship Show Rough Collie Dogs |
Lesley Chalmers |
Cathy Cooper |
|
Viv Anderton |
|
Miranda Blake |
|
Tracey Jackson |
|
Stephen Webb |
|
Crawford-Taylor |
|
John Catliff |
|
Geoff Duffield |
|
Delia Moores |
|
Mr W J Henderson |
|
Jenny Miller |
|
Collie Club of Wales Ch Show Rough Collie Dogs |
Tony Iley |
Collie Club of Wales Ch Show Rough Collie Bitches |
Alan Staniland |
Collie Club of Wales Ch Show Best in Show |
Bev White |
Collie Club of Wales Ch Show Smooth Collies |
Kirsty Russell |
Welsh Kennel Club |
Gina Stilwell |
London and Provincial Collie Club Open Show Show 1 - Rough and Smooth Collies |
Ray McDonald |
Mrs Emily Bemelmans |
|
London and Provincial Collie Club Open Show Best in Show |
Gina Stilwell |
London and Provincial Collie Club Open Show Rough Collies |
Abby Lusty |
Lynda Nicholas |
|
Christina Bailey |
|
Penny Sewell |
|
Mr A Easdon |
|
Scottish Collie Club Open Show Rough Collies |
Wilma Brodie |
Jane Stevens |
|
London Collie Club Open Show Smooth Collies |
Lynda Nicholas |
London Collie Club Open Show Rough Collies |
Terrie Cousins-Brown |
Claire Norman |
|
Kevin Young |
|
Paul Battigan |
|
Gareth Brown |
|
Janine Hanson |
|
Miss J M Fort |
|
Brenda Cooney |
|
Yorkshire Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Bitches |
Duna Jones |
Yorkshire Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Dogs |
Jo Hodges |
Yorkshire Collie Club Ch Show Smooth Collies |
Georgina Howard |
Ayrshire Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Dogs |
Wendy Musty |
Ayrshire Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Bitches |
Doreen Clarke |
Collie Association Ch Show Rough Collie Dogs |
Lene Newman |
Collie Association Ch Show Best of Breed Rough and Best in Show |
Caroe Smedley |
Collie Association Ch Show Smooth Collies |
Jenny Miller |
Collie Club of Wales Open Show Smooth Collies |
Sue Hawkins |
Collie Club of Wales Open Show Rough Collies and Smooth SAC |
Sue Beare |
Smooth Collie Club Ch Show Rough and Smooth Collies |
Janice Cook |
Tunbridge Wells Rough Collies |
Shelley Skinner |
Leeds Rough Collies |
Tom Johnston |
Working and Pastoral Breeds of Scotland Rough Collies |
Tom Mather |
Midland Counties Rough Collies |
Albert Wight |
Doug Bedford |
|
Midland Collie Club Open Show Rough Collies |
Wilma Brodie |
Lancs and Cheshire Open Show Rough Collies |
Catherine Hollinshead |
South Wales Kennel Association Rough Collies |
Tracy Gartland |
British Collie Club Open Show Best in Show |
Sue Hawkins |
British Collie Club Open Show Rough Collies |
Karen Johnston |
British Collie Club Open Show Smooth Collies |
Stefani Flower |
LKA Rough Collies |
Graham Hill |
Blackpool Rough Collies |
Geoff Hyde |
2023
Show and Link to Critique |
Judge |
Ann French |
|
Abby Lusty |
|
Stacy Steven |
|
Tracey Goodwin |
|
Uwe Nolke |
|
Georgina Howard |
|
Simon Burton |
|
Shelley Skinner |
|
Stella Clark |
|
Christine Collins |
|
John Congdon |
|
Gill Whittaker |
|
Stefani Flower |
|
Denis Beardsworth |
|
Val Tame |
|
Derek Allsopp |
|
Fran Kaye |
|
Wendy Musty |
|
Jill Kelly |
|
Anne Mar-Gerrison |
|
Simon Walder |
|
Andre Scott |
|
Di Collino |
|
Gwen Beaden |
|
Smooth Collie Club of GB Open Show 2 Rough Collies |
Jo White |
Geoff Duffield |
|
Smooth Collie Club of GB Open Show 1 Smooth Collies |
Jo Denton |
Emily Bemelmans |
|
Jane Lindley |
|
Anne Smith |
|
Lancs and Cheshire Collie Club Ch show Rough Collie dogs |
Val Brown |
Lancs and Cheshire Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Bitches |
Roz Makepeace |
Mike Vincent |
|
Lucy Mottram |
|
Scottish Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie bitches |
Grenville Francis |
Angela Harvey |
|
Janine Hanson |
|
Yorkshire Collie Club Open Show Smooth Collies |
Paul Richardson |
Barrie Croft |
|
Janine Hanson |
|
Robin Searle |
|
Bev White |
|
John Catliff |
|
Karen Colman-Smith |
|
Darren Clarke |
|
Liam Kelly |
|
Sheila Hall |
|
Lynda Nicholas |
|
John Catliff |
|
Terry McGowan |
|
Tan Nagrecha |
|
Stuart Mallard |
|
Tina May |
|
Collie Association Open Show - Show 1 Rough Collies |
Stacy Steven |
Collie Association Open Show - Show 2 Rough Collies |
Lorraine Quince |
Collie Association Open Show - Show 1 Smooth Collies |
Margaret Shipp |
Collie Association Open Show - Show 2 Smooth Collies |
Sheila Carlton |
Collie Association - BIS |
Jean Kenny |
Dave Gordon |
|
Louise Walker |
|
Mr W Browne Cole |
|
Karen Angier |
|
Christine Gillingham |
|
Tracey Wilkinson |
|
Jan Milligan |
|
Stephanie Presdee |
|
Gina Stilwell |
|
Gina Stilwell |
|
Rodney Oldham |
|
Marianne Benton |
|
Marianne Benton |
|
Wendy Musty |
|
Sue Randall |
|
Lene Newman |
|
Eleanor Kitchen |
|
Maxine Mellish |
|
London and Provincial Collie Club Ch Show Best in Show |
Stella Clark |
London and Provincial Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Bitches |
Steve Barrett |
London and Provincial Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Dogs |
Derek Allsopp |
London and Provincial Collie Club Ch Show Smooth Collies |
Bridgette Bodle |
M Glover-Guest |
|
Howard Ogden |
|
National Working and Pastoral Breeds Rough Collies |
Pat Brooker |
Lana (Lavika) |
|
Jake Walsh |
|
Michelle Davis |
|
Yorkshire Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Dogs |
Philip Sargeant |
Yorkshire Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Bitches |
Daphne Iley |
Darlington - Rough Collies |
Steve Hall |
Shelley Skinner |
|
Fran Kaye |
|
Espen Engh |
|
Stephen Clark |
|
Lorraine Quince |
|
Sue Hawkins |
|
Ayrshire Collie Club Ch Show Rough Collie Bitches |
Rod Slater |
Lynda Nicholas |
|
Collie Club of Wales Open Show Rough Collies and SAC Smooths |
Doug Bedford |
Collie Club of Wales Open Show Smooths and SAC Roughs |
Georgina Howard |
Collie Assocation Ch Show Rough Collie dogs |
Frank Kane |
Collie Association Ch Show Rough Collie bitches |
Jayne Llewellyn |
Collie Association Ch Show |
Mrs P Wilkinson |
Collie Association Ch Show Smooth Collies |
Richard Kinsey |
West of England Collie Society Open Show Smooth Collies |
Felicity Snook |
West of England Collie Society Open Show Rough Collies |
Shelley Skinner |
Exonian Canine Association Rough Collies |
Stephanee Presdee |
City of Birmingham Rough Collies |
Derek Smith |
City of Birmingham Smooth Collies |
Derek Smith |
Frank H Whyte |
|
Derek Smith |
|
Richard Kinsey |
|
Lynne Salt |
|
Kevin Young |
|
Shelley Skinner |
|
Katrina Rettie |
|
Louise Walker |
|
Joshua Blackburn |
|
Sally Duffin |
|
Maxine Mellish |