Spaying or neutering should be an individual decision rather than something carried out automatically at the same age for every dog.
The appropriate decision may depend upon the dog's sex, breed, expected adult size, physical maturity, health, temperament, living arrangements and the owner's ability to prevent an accidental mating.
This article includes published research, surveys, professional opinions and personal experiences. These do not all reach the same conclusions. Survey findings and individual opinions are included because they form an important part of the continuing debate, but they should not be interpreted as proving that every dog will experience the same outcome.
Early spaying and neutering: positive or negative?
In the following video, David Harris discusses early spaying and neutering, possible health and temperament effects and some of the questions owners may wish to consider.
There is no single age that is necessarily right for every dog. Some dogs may have a medical, welfare or management reason for earlier neutering, while for others it may be appropriate to wait until they are more physically mature or to leave them entire.
The decision should be discussed with a veterinary surgeon who is familiar with the individual dog and with any health concerns affecting the breed.
What do spaying and neutering mean?
Spaying a bitch
A conventional spay removes the ovaries, usually either by ovariectomy, in which the ovaries are removed, or ovariohysterectomy, in which the ovaries and uterus are removed. Both procedures prevent pregnancy and stop future seasons.
A laparoscopic or “keyhole” spay normally removes the ovaries through smaller incisions. It is not suitable in every situation and may not be available at every veterinary practice.
Neutering a male
Male neutering or castration normally involves the surgical removal of both testicles. This prevents the dog from fathering puppies and substantially reduces testosterone production.
Vasectomy and temporary hormonal implants are possible alternatives in some circumstances. These are discussed later in this article.
Possible benefits
Benefits for bitches
- Prevents pregnancy and accidental litters.
- Prevents pyometra after a conventional spay. Pyometra is a serious and potentially fatal infection of the uterus.
- Prevents diseases of the ovaries when both ovaries are removed.
- Avoids the practical difficulties of managing seasons.
- May reduce the risk of mammary tumours, although the size of that benefit and its relationship to the timing of surgery continue to be discussed.
- Prevents false pregnancies caused by subsequent reproductive cycles, although a bitch should not normally be spayed during an active false pregnancy unless there is a medical reason.
Benefits for male dogs
- Prevents testicular cancer and other diseases arising within the testicles.
- Can reduce the likelihood of benign enlargement of the prostate and some testosterone-dependent conditions.
- May reduce roaming, persistent scent marking, mounting and some forms of conflict between male dogs when those behaviours are driven by testosterone.
- Prevents the dog from fathering an accidental litter.
Important: Neutering is not a guaranteed cure for behavioural problems. Fear, anxiety, frustration, guarding and learned aggression may remain unchanged and, in some dogs, reducing testosterone may make confidence-related behaviour worse.
Physical maturity and the growth plates
Growth plates are areas of developing cartilage near the ends of young bones. They gradually close as a puppy matures. Reproductive hormones are involved in this process, so removing the gonads before physical maturity may delay growth-plate closure and result in slightly longer limb bones.
The age at which growth plates close varies according to the particular bone, the individual dog, breed and adult size. Small breeds generally mature earlier than large and giant breeds.
The diagram above gives approximate ranges and should not be treated as a timetable that applies precisely to every dog. Research has found associations between the timing of neutering and some orthopaedic conditions, but the degree of risk varies considerably between breeds and between male and female dogs.
Canine consultant Emma Judson has argued that the hormones produced by the reproductive organs play a role in growth-plate closure and later muscular development. Her view is that dogs should not routinely be neutered before they are fully grown and that owners of larger breeds should consider waiting beyond 18 months.
This is a professional opinion included as part of the debate. It is not a universal rule, and an individual dog may have health or welfare reasons for being neutered sooner.
Research, surveys and differing opinions
Research into neutering can be difficult to interpret. Many studies are retrospective or observational: they examine veterinary records or ask owners about dogs that have already been neutered. Such studies can identify an association, but they cannot always show that neutering itself caused the condition.
Breed, inherited risk, lifestyle, body weight, reason for neutering, quality of care and the age reached by the dog can all influence the results. A finding in one breed should not automatically be applied to every other breed.
A widely quoted survey of Vizslas reported associations between neutering and increased diagnoses of several cancers and behavioural disorders. Reported findings included:
- Neutered dogs in the survey had higher reported rates of mast-cell cancer, lymphoma, other cancers and cancers combined than intact dogs.
- Spayed females in the survey had a higher reported incidence of haemangiosarcoma than intact females.
- Dogs neutered at six months or younger had increased reported odds of behavioural disorders, including separation anxiety, noise phobia, timidity, excitability, submissive urination, aggression, hyperactivity and fear biting.
- Neutered Vizslas were reported to have a greater risk of fear of storms than intact Vizslas.
- Younger age at neutering was associated with an earlier age of diagnosis for several of the conditions examined.
The figures frequently quoted from this survey include 3.5 times the incidence of mast-cell cancer, 4.3 times the incidence of lymphoma and higher combined cancer incidence in neutered dogs. These figures describe associations found within the surveyed Vizsla population. They do not establish that neutering caused each illness and should not be assumed to represent the risk in Rough Collies or in every breed.
Further reading and opinions retained from the original page:
Opinion and discussion concerning behavioural changes in male dogs
Ten-minute behaviour consultation: male neutering
Case-control study published in the Journal of Small Animal Practice
Weighing the risks and benefits of early spaying and neutering
Opinion: Dog First
The following section summarises an article originally reproduced courtesy of Dog First. It presents the author’s opinion about routine early neutering and the responsibilities associated with keeping an entire dog.
The opinions and conclusions belong to the original author. Some of the research discussed is older, and some claims remain disputed. They are retained here as an important contribution to the debate rather than being presented as universal veterinary advice.
The role of the gonads
In male mammals the gonads are the testicles, while in females they are the ovaries. In addition to producing sperm or eggs, the gonads produce hormones including testosterone, oestrogen and progesterone.
These hormones are involved in reproduction, puberty, bone development, muscle mass, metabolism and growth-plate closure. The author’s concern is that removing them before puberty may have effects extending beyond preventing reproduction.
Possible benefits acknowledged by the author
The Dog First article acknowledges that neutering prevents unwanted litters and removes the possibility of testicular or ovarian cancer. It may also reduce certain hormone-related conditions and behaviours, including roaming and conflict between males competing over a bitch in season.
Cancer concerns raised in the article
The article refers to studies that reported associations between neutering and an increased incidence of certain cancers. These included cardiac tumours, osteosarcoma and some prostate tumours.
One study examining Rottweilers reported a higher incidence of osteosarcoma in dogs neutered before one year of age. Other studies discussed in the article reported an association between sterilisation and cardiac tumours, particularly in females.
The article also disputes the suggestion that castration prevents prostate cancer. Castration can considerably reduce benign enlargement of the prostate, but it does not guarantee protection from malignant prostate cancer.
Context: These studies identified statistical associations in particular populations. The findings do not mean that neutering will cause cancer in an individual dog, and the degree of any association may differ by breed, sex and age at neutering.
Bone growth and joint concerns
The article refers to work by Stubbs and Bloomberg and by Salmeri and colleagues. These studies reported that dogs neutered before physical maturity may experience delayed growth-plate closure and a small increase in adult height.
It also quotes the opinion of canine sports medicine specialist Dr Chris Zink, who has discussed the possibility that differences in the timing of growth-plate closure could alter the proportions and mechanics of the limbs.
The author considers this a possible explanation for associations reported between early neutering and cranial cruciate ligament injury or hip dysplasia.
Other concerns raised
The original article also discusses possible associations with:
- Hypothyroidism in some studied populations.
- Urinary incontinence in spayed bitches.
- Infectious disease in puppies sterilised at a very young age in shelter environments.
- Weight gain and altered metabolism.
- Development of a softer, thicker or woollier coat.
The author states that the altered coat commonly described by owners and groomers was largely anecdotal at the time the article was written. Photographs and an owner’s account are included later on this page.
The author’s conclusion
The author’s view is that, where an owner can reliably prevent mating, neutering should normally be postponed until after puberty and physical maturity. The article recognises that this may mean waiting longer for larger, slower-maturing breeds.
The author also argues that population control cannot depend upon neutering alone and calls for microchipping, responsible breeding, secure ownership and stronger enforcement against abandonment and irresponsible dog ownership.
Opinion: Dr Karen Becker
Dr Karen Becker has publicly argued that owners and veterinary surgeons should give greater consideration to the timing of neutering and to the possible health effects of removing reproductive hormones before maturity.
Her position also stresses that anyone choosing to keep a dog entire carries an absolute responsibility to prevent an unplanned mating.
Responsible owners must protect their intact dogs from unplanned breeding. Where an owner can guarantee that a dog will not be allowed to mate, waiting until after puberty may allow possible health benefits. Where this cannot be guaranteed, sterilisation may be the safer and more responsible option.
The paragraph above is a concise summary of the opinion expressed in the original article and is not presented as a direct quotation.
Possible health considerations
Neutering has both potential benefits and potential disadvantages. The balance is not identical for every dog.
Orthopaedic conditions
Studies in several breeds have found associations between early neutering and conditions such as hip dysplasia, cranial cruciate ligament disease and some other joint disorders. These associations are more apparent in certain large breeds, and results differ between breeds and sexes.
This does not mean that every early-neutered dog will develop a joint problem. Genetics, body weight, exercise, injury, nutrition and physical conformation are also important.
Urinary incontinence
Some spayed bitches develop urinary sphincter mechanism incontinence. It can occur months or years after surgery and appears to be more common in some larger breeds.
Most affected bitches can be managed with veterinary treatment, but this possible risk should form part of the discussion before surgery.
Body weight
Neutered dogs may require fewer calories, and some experience increased appetite. Weight gain is not inevitable, but food portions and body condition should be monitored after surgery.
Excess weight itself increases the risk of diabetes, joint disease, breathing difficulties and several other health problems.
Cancer
Removal of the testicles or ovaries prevents cancer arising in those organs. Spaying also prevents pyometra when the uterus and ovarian influence have been removed.
Conversely, breed-specific studies have reported associations between neutering and an altered incidence of osteosarcoma, haemangiosarcoma, lymphoma, mast-cell tumours and some other cancers.
The results are not consistent across all breeds. An association found in veterinary records or an owner survey does not, by itself, prove that neutering caused the cancer.
Hypothyroidism and immune-mediated disease
Some studies and breed health surveys have reported higher rates of hypothyroidism or particular immune-mediated disorders in neutered dogs. These findings may be influenced by breed, age and other differences between intact and neutered populations.
Putting risk into perspective: A reported increase in relative risk can sound alarming without the original rate being given. For example, doubling a rare risk from one dog in 1,000 to two dogs in 1,000 is different from doubling a common risk from one in ten to two in ten.
Owners should consider the actual incidence of a condition, the strength of the evidence and whether the research relates to their dog’s breed and sex.
Behaviour after neutering
Testosterone-related behaviours may improve following castration. These can include roaming in search of bitches, persistent urine marking, mounting and some competition between male dogs.
However, behaviour is influenced by genetics, early experience, training, learning, health, fear and the dog’s environment. Castration will not automatically calm an energetic dog or cure aggression.
A nervous or insecure dog should be assessed carefully before castration. Testosterone can contribute to confidence, and some owners and behaviourists report increased fearfulness or anxiety after neutering.
Owner surveys have reported associations between neutering and behaviours including noise sensitivity, separation anxiety, timidity, excitability, aggression and fear biting.
Other studies and clinical experience suggest that castration can reduce roaming, mounting, marking and some male-to-male aggression.
These apparently conflicting results demonstrate why the dog’s reason for displaying a behaviour should be assessed before surgery. An owner survey records observations and experiences, but it cannot always determine whether neutering caused the reported behaviour.
Responsible ownership of an entire dog
Leaving a dog entire does not mean allowing it to breed. Anyone choosing to postpone or avoid neutering must be able to manage the dog responsibly.
- Keep the garden and property secure.
- Do not allow an entire dog to roam.
- Keep a bitch completely separated from entire males throughout her season.
- Remember that mating can occur very quickly and through surprisingly small gaps.
- Do not rely upon dog pants, crates placed next to each other or supervision from another room.
- Use a lead when there is any risk of encountering a bitch in season.
- Ensure identification and microchip details remain current.
- Seek veterinary advice immediately if an accidental mating occurs.
Owners who cannot guarantee this level of management should discuss sterilisation with their veterinary surgeon.
Alternatives to conventional neutering
Temporary hormonal implant for male dogs
A deslorelin implant can temporarily suppress fertility and testosterone production in a male dog. It is inserted beneath the skin in a procedure similar to microchipping.
The implant may help an owner and veterinary behaviourist assess how reduced testosterone could affect a dog before permanent castration is considered. Its effect is temporary, although the exact duration varies between individual dogs.
A dog is not necessarily infertile immediately after the implant is inserted. There may also be an initial temporary increase in testosterone-related behaviour. Owners must follow their veterinary surgeon’s instructions and continue preventing mating until advised that the implant has taken effect.
Vasectomy
A vasectomy prevents sperm from entering the semen but leaves the testicles and their hormone production in place. The dog remains hormonally entire and may continue to show sexual behaviour and interest in bitches in season.
Vasectomy is not routinely offered by every veterinary practice and does not provide the health effects associated with removing the testicles.
Ovary-sparing spay
An ovary-sparing spay removes the uterus while retaining one or both ovaries. This prevents pregnancy while maintaining reproductive hormone production.
The bitch may continue to show signs associated with hormonal cycles and attract male dogs. Retaining ovarian tissue also retains some hormone-related health considerations. The exact procedure, continuing risks and management requirements must be discussed with a veterinary surgeon experienced in the technique.
Laparoscopic spay
A laparoscopic spay is a minimally invasive procedure usually involving removal of the ovaries through small incisions. It still removes the principal source of reproductive hormones and should not be confused with an ovary-sparing spay.
Additional opinions and further reading retained from the original article:
Neutering dogs – an in-depth opinion
Spaying and neutering: discussion of possible health effects
Time4Dogs opinion on spaying and neutering
Dr Karen Becker’s discussion of neutering and cancer risk
Dogs Naturally opinion: reasons to reconsider spaying and neutering
Coat changes following neutering
Some owners and groomers report that a dog’s coat becomes softer, thicker, woollier or more difficult to maintain after neutering. This is frequently called a “spay coat”, although it may occur in both males and females.
It appears to be particularly noticeable in some long-coated and silky-coated breeds. It does not happen to every dog, and the extent of any change varies considerably.
Age, inherited coat type, grooming, nutrition, health and normal ageing can also affect coat texture and density. The photographs below are examples and should not be interpreted as proof that every neutered Rough Collie will develop the same coat.
Examples of a spayed Rough Collie coat
In a Rough Collie, an altered coat may contain considerably more soft undercoat. This can make it prone to matting and more difficult for an elderly owner or someone with limited mobility to maintain.
Regular grooming through to the skin is important. If the coat changes suddenly, becomes thin or is accompanied by skin problems, weight change or lethargy, veterinary advice should be sought because hormonal or other medical conditions may also affect the coat.
A Cocker Spaniel owner’s experience
The following account was sent to Collielife by the owner of a male Cocker Spaniel. It records what she observed after her dog was neutered at five years old.
This is an individual owner’s experience and opinion. It cannot prove that neutering caused every reported physical or behavioural change, but it is retained as an example of the concerns reported by some owners.
I found your article about spayed dogs while looking for information confirming changes in coats before and after neutering.
My male Cocker Spaniel was neutered at the age of five following advice from our vet concerning the risk of testicular cancer. His coat changed from a beautiful, silky red coat to an unmanageable, blond and woolly coat.
The other effects I noticed were weight gain of approximately 2kg and incessant begging for food. He even started eating bread, which had not interested him before.
I also noticed an increase in his separation anxiety and barking. In other words, he appeared more anxious than before neutering.
I had not been in favour of neutering my dog, although my view at the time was emotional rather than based upon research. Having now observed the effects, I would not make the same decision automatically for another dog.
When I was growing up in Italy, we had five German Shepherd Dogs and none was neutered. We kept them securely in our garden. My intact Cocker Spaniel had not persistently tried to mount other dogs during walks and rarely became involved in fights with other males.
I believe responsible ownership, secure containment and effective rules are important ways of preventing unwanted litters.
The woolly effect became progressively worse with further grooming. We groomed him once or twice a year and, particularly during July and August, sometimes had to clip the coat very short.
The other changes I found difficult were a constant appetite, increased barking and increased separation anxiety. He would follow me everywhere, even when I went to the bathroom.
Until then I had assumed the last two changes were due to stress or age, but I began to wonder whether hormones had also played a part.
On the positive side, he rarely became excited around other male dogs in the park, although there were still occasional disagreements. I therefore could not say that neutering had produced a major improvement in that respect.
Annalisa, London
The owner’s account has been lightly edited for spelling, clarity and privacy without changing the substance of her experience.
Questions to consider before deciding
Why is it being considered?
Is the reason medical, behavioural, to prevent breeding or simply because the dog has reached a particular age?
Has the dog matured?
Consider the dog’s breed, sex, expected adult size and physical development rather than using one age for every dog.
What are the breed risks?
Ask whether the breed has known risks involving joints, cancers, urinary incontinence, coat change or other relevant conditions.
Is behaviour the reason?
Establish whether the behaviour is driven by hormones, fear, frustration, pain or learned experience before assuming neutering will resolve it.
Can mating be prevented?
Be realistic about the home, garden, other dogs, walking arrangements and the management of a bitch throughout her season.
Are alternatives appropriate?
Discuss temporary implants, vasectomy, ovary-sparing surgery or delaying the operation where these are appropriate and available.
Collielife’s view
Collielife does not support routine early spaying or neutering simply because a dog has reached six months of age.
In my opinion, owners should be given balanced information about the recognised benefits, possible risks, breed differences, physical maturity, behaviour and available alternatives before consenting to surgery.
Where there is no urgent medical or welfare reason, and where an owner can reliably prevent an accidental mating, I believe there is good reason to discuss waiting until the dog is physically mature.
This does not mean that no dog should be neutered. Spaying prevents pyometra and unwanted pregnancy, while castration can be beneficial for particular medical conditions and some hormone-driven behaviours.
The decision should be made for the individual dog rather than being based upon a blanket rule either for or against neutering.
Sources and further information
British Small Animal Veterinary Association – neutering position statement
Journal of Small Animal Practice – neutering case-control study
British Association of Holistic Veterinary Surgeons – gonad-sparing sterilisation
Ten-minute behaviour consultation – male neutering
Weighing the risks and benefits of early spaying and neutering
Veterinary disclaimer: This article is intended to encourage an informed discussion about spaying and neutering. It includes published research, surveys, professional opinions and personal experiences, some of which reach different conclusions.
It is not a substitute for individual veterinary advice. Always discuss your dog’s health, breed, behaviour, maturity and living arrangements with your veterinary surgeon before making a decision.